Page 1 of 2

Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2021 11:52 am
by kurtbob
I tried starting my car, heard the fuel pump run for a few seconds, but the car would not turn over. After that, pushed the starter button and heard a relay click several times. I assumed I had a bad relay, but replaced both the main and fuel relay. The car still will not turn over. Any ideas?

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2021 5:46 pm
by breton
I'm assuming you've checked the batter voltage and it's charged above 12.7. On the Gen3, I discovered a recurrent problem with the ground cable from the battery to the frame due to corrosion. I unscrewed the ground cable from the frame and wire-brushed both the frame and the cable. Re-attached and, voila, it started! I've since made it habit to also check the ground from the frame to the transmission, for the same reason. Wouldn't hurt to check the positive connection at the starter, as well. You may want to put a volt meter on the battery as well, to see if the voltage take a big drop (below 12.0) when you push the starter button. That could be indicative of a failing battery that has OK voltage, but insufficient amps to start the car.

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Sat Mar 13, 2021 9:55 pm
by kurtbob
I just took it off the trickle charger, but I'll check all the grounds. Thanks!

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2021 3:45 pm
by JBPDXOR
Check or replace the Crank Sensor. If the sensor is bad, Nothing happens.. no start

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2021 6:07 pm
by kurtbob
JBPDXOR wrote:Check or replace the Crank Sensor. If the sensor is bad, Nothing happens.. no start
How do I check the sensor? Do the relays do the clicking when the sensor is bad?

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2021 6:12 pm
by turnnpoint
Sounds like the problem I had. It was the starter itself. First try putting the car in gear and rocking the car back and forth. Then try to start normally. If that doesn't work, try putting the car in 2nd gear, switch on, press and hold the starter and have someone rock the car forward. Be ready to depress the clutch as soon as the starter tries to engage if it does. I wouldn't hold the button very long trying this. This would sometimes work for us. The problem ended up being the starter itself. Call Kevin at Comprent - he is familiar with the problem.

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Sun Mar 14, 2021 9:17 pm
by kurtbob
turnnpoint wrote:Sounds like the problem I had. It was the starter itself. First try putting the car in gear and rocking the car back and forth. Then try to start normally. If that doesn't work, try putting the car in 2nd gear, switch on, press and hold the starter and have someone rock the car forward. Be ready to depress the clutch as soon as the starter tries to engage if it does. I wouldn't hold the button very long trying this. This would sometimes work for us. The problem ended up being the starter itself. Call Kevin at Comprent - he is familiar with the problem.

Thanks! I did suspect the starter at first, because last year it sometimes didn't "hit" on the first try, but did on the 2nd try.

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 11:42 am
by breton
Or the "old school" hammer on the solenoid trick... ;-)

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 1:27 pm
by kurtbob
breton wrote:Or the "old school" hammer on the solenoid trick... ;-)

Yep.I've already tried that trick, but it didn't work. Bummer

Re: Car won't start - But relays are good

PostPosted: Mon Mar 15, 2021 2:15 pm
by JBPDXOR
Kurt,
You can buy a crankshaft sensor online for $9.00 up to $28. I would just shotgun and replace. Even if the problem is not solved you will have an important spare part.

Part # BE8Z-6C315-A